Honey, I Shrunk The Coalition!

My, how the tables have turned! A little more than eighteen months ago Zares of Gregor Golobič floated the idea of some fundamental changes to Slovenian referendum legislation. What on the surface looked like a noble idea, had way to many drawbacks, but for purposes of this post suffice it to say that among other things this junior coalition party wanted to institute a “Referendum Day” or two where all referendum bids filed until a certain date would be voted on (Read The Road To Hell Is Paved With Good Intentions if you want to jog your memory).

The Boy with the Flute is a mascot of RTVSLO ever since it was created as RTV Ljubljana (source)

Today the government of Borut Pahor and Zares in particular are in a situation where such provisions (had they been passed in time) would most likely kill one or more key pieces of reform legislation which the coalition somehow managed to squeeze through the parliament despite copious amounts of shit being thrown at it.

Notably this goes for the famed Law on Menial Work (which was, truth be told, vetoed by the National Council hours ago and will have to be voted on again by the National Assembly) and especially for the new law on national radio and television (RTV Slovenija) which was passed last week and which (again) brings sweeping changes to the institution and (according to the Ministry of Culture) is returning the now-state-run media back into the public domain.

State vs. Public

A quick but necessary digression: Soon after Janez Janša won 2004 elections (so soon in fact that the LDS did not yet have the time to fall apart) a new law on RTVSLO was passed by the parliament which turned the former into a full-blooded state radio and television, mostly through changes in composition of supervisory and programming boards and election of its members and (further down) by altering the way Radio and TV chiefs were appointed.

The changes, however, were sold as “more quality programming for less money” since of the more debated provisions of the law was the so called RTV-fee (which was set at EUR 12) held the most tangible value. Everyone who’s ever worked in media knows that you never get more (quality) content for less money, but since RTVSLO was, is, and will be a money-guzzling-bottomless-pit and since quality of programming already at that time left a lot to be desired, it wasn’t a hard sell. And even so the law was barely confirmed on a referendum.

Honey, I shrunk the coalition!

The new law was passed on 20 October with an ordinary majority and immediately caused a bit of a rift in the largest coalition party as Andrej Magajna (leader of non-parliamentary Christian Socialist party, elected as MP on a Social Democrats‘ ticket) broke ranks and gave the crucial thirtieth signature needed by opposition Slovene Democratic Party (SDS) and Slovene National Party (SNS) to call a referendum on the freshly minted law. Furthermore Magajna left SD’s club and declared himself an indpendent.

One vote less in a squabble-prone left wing coalition is quite a price to pay for a single piece of legislation. This proves that the law, which was drafted in the ministry of culture (a portfolio held by Zares’ Majda Širca) has such a strong backing in the government and PM Pahor personally that he was willing to see his majority in the parliament reduced to 47 votes. just a vote above the single-vote majority.

Cynics will obviously say that this is a small price to pay to have RTVSLO shaped according to Zares’ and Pahor’s wishes, and to an extent that is true. The true question therefore is whether RTVSLO will truly be returned to the public domain as the coalition claims or will it be further politicised as the opposition claims. Janez Janša’s SDS crying foul on political influence over RTVSLO is of course a classic case of the pot calling the kettle black, but this does not automatically mean that the law is good. But it does provide some basis for gradual comeback of quality content and serious journalism to what supposedly wants to be the Slovenian BBC. But nothing will change just because there’s a new law in place. Just sayin’

Oh, the irony!

Wait. What? Who said there’s a new law in place? The referendum bid was successful, which means that the voters will have the final say in the matter. And this is where we come full circle to the beginning of the post. It is somewhat ironic that today it is the opposition which wants to institute a “Referendum day”, mostly on the grounds that there are numerous referendums being mulled (RTVSLO, law on menial work and pension reform among others) and “since we’re at it, we might just vote on them all in one go”.

We’ll neglect the fact that this is a rather poor attempt at shooting down Pahor’s government at the expense of an overhaul this country badly needs and rather focus on the fact that Zares responded fiercely to the idea. Not just because they see the referendum as a “waste of taxpayers’ time and money” (which is the official party position) but also because holding a referendum on 17 April would a) probably sink the law by default as it would not be voted on on merit but as a protest vote against the government and b) would – if it somehow survived – come into force on 1 January 2012, more than a year from now. Which is precisely one of the drawbacks of Zares’ idea pengovsky pointed out a year-and-a-half ago.

Yes, I am feeling rather smug 😀

Enhanced by Zemanta

Published by


Agent provocateur and an occasional scribe.

7 thoughts on “Honey, I Shrunk The Coalition!”

  1. Wow, with all that’s been going on, the really important developments seem to escape Slovenian media. Coalition is down to just 1 vote above the majority? Combined with hostile SNS (which in the past could be convinced to vote in favour of government’s (left or right) proposals, but not any more) and most likely hostile independent MPs (especially to neoliberal legislation), this spells serious problems for the government. Sure, you have 2 MPs who represent minority who usually go with the government, but sometimes these two are also against them. And than there’s all those interest groups against them (students, unions, lobbies inside the government such as SD’s energy lobby, some of Zares’s antimilitary MPs, Desus propensioners…). Certainy not a walk in the park for Pahor…
    Heh, I guess Drnovsek knew what his was doing with those huge coalitions of his 🙂

  2. Recently on MMC RTV Janša spoke (chat) to the people. Here’s my number one (sorry, slovene):

    Tadeja: Lepo pozdravljeni g. Janša. Prejšnji zakon o RTV je
    obljubljal zmanjšanje naročnine. Naročnina se res ni povečevala glede na inflacijo, vendar volilci smo to razumeli, da se bo znesek na položnici zmanjšal. Ste de od prejšnjega mandata kaj naučili, da ni bilo dobro in bi v prihodnjem mandatu spremenili.? Po moje je samo vpr. časa kdaj zopet postanete prvi minister.
    Janez Jansa: Važna je realna cena. V času, ko se naročnina za RTV ni povečala, je na manjšo realno vrednost naročnine poleg inflacije vplivala tudi realna rast plač v Sloveniji. V tem času so se po podatkih statističnega urada plače povečale za 24%.

  3. Jacob, his saying that “it’s cheaper because of inflation and the rise of wages” is meaningless sophistry that only the most devout followers actually believe. You should have also asked him why the program didn’t get better (as in, more rock concert footage, more international politic programming and more urban culture reports). What’s that? Some people think that wouldn’t be better, that the program would in fact be better if there was more sports? Or more reports on the shenanigans of the European royal families? More Latin American soap operas? My point: not only was the promise of cheaper TV bullshit, the promise of “better programming” is something that every single one of the viewers can understand differently and thus completely impossible to fulfill. I can’t believe nobody called them out on it at the time of the referendum and that people actually voted on the platform of “better programming” without seeing the utter stupidity of that promise.

Comments are closed.