Arbitration Agreement Approved (Hic Rhodos, Hic Salta)

With almost 100% of the vote counted the Arbitration Agreement between Slovenia and Croatia was approved with 51,49 percent in favour. The turnout was slightly over 42 percent, which – although much lower than anticipated – is still among the highest on Slovenian referenda.

20100606 blog Arbitration Agreement Approved (Hic Rhodos, Hic Salta)
PM Borut Pahor following a tight referendum victory (photo: Marko Miščević/Jutarnji list)

The result is good news for Slovenia as it paves the way for solving the Slovenia – Croatia border dispute in a manner acceptable to both sides. This defuses a potentially very dangerous situation which has only recently (and temporarily) improved with PMs Borut Pahor and Jadranka Kosor seizing the initiative and hammering out a deal which received a lacklustre performance on both sides of the border. And yet, this is the first time in nineteen years an agreement was reached, which is an achievement in its own right.

This is even better news for Prime Minister Borut Pahor who won a huge political victory over opposition leader Janez Janša. Politically speaking, there was a lot riding on this one and Janša, hell, the entire right wing lost. True, they lost by the smallest of margin. But given the unpopularity of Pahor’s government (most of the electorate would not touch it with a ten-foot pole), winning this referendum should be like a walk in the park for Janša. But SDS leader failed to make this a referendum on Pahor’s government, or – even better – Pahor succeeded in separating the issue from the general unpopularity of his government, which makes today’s victory at the polls even more .

Responses from the losing side were predictable enough. That “only 21% voted yes“. That “the country remains split“. That “traitors won”. That “everybody lost”. And – perversely – that “now it the time to start working together”. It all came from the same side which proposed that Slovenia demand territory south of Savudrija and that approving the agreement is akin to losing Klagenfurt (Celovec) in 1920 (for the record – Slovenia didn’t “lose” Celovec then. It didn’t get it in the first place). On the other hand, responses from the winning side didn’t excel either, but their statements were definitely more muted in excitement.

Prime minister Pahor is halfway there to winning a gamble of galactic proportions. He succeeded where PMs Peterle, Drnovšek, Bajuk, Rop and Janša had failed. This alone gets him a spot in the history books. But if the arbitration court decides (as is expected to) favourably both to Slovenia and Croatia, then he should probably be promoted from a politician to a statesman. I know some of you are diving for your barf bags after reading the last sentence, but today’s vote really is that big.

However, Pahor is not yet there. Slovenia and Croatia must now set up the court as well as prepare memoranda detailing their respective cases and real work had only begun. Hic Rhodos, hic salta.


13 Comments to “Arbitration Agreement Approved (Hic Rhodos, Hic Salta)”

  1. Dr. ARF Says:

    At least the work can begin now the bickering and its resulting immobilism are finished. Of course, this will undoubtedly start a new round of bickering, but at least the train is starting to move…

  2. Carlos González Says:

    Živjo Pengovsky,
    ¿What do you think about Janša’s statement yesterday? He said that his party won’t support the ratification of Croatia’s accession treaty until the arbitration team decide on the matter. And, as we know, Slovenian parliament should aprove it with a majority of 2/3.

    Is there any date for an output of the arbitration? Will he keep his word?

    Cheers from Madrid!

  3. pengovsky Says:

    @Dr. Arf: True. For the moment this issue is off the table and real work can commence.

    @Carlos: Yes, I saw that statement too, but for the moment I’d let it slide. Croatian entry is not around the corner and a lot can happen in the mean time. If nothing else, Slovenia will hold parliamentary elections before that and the way things stand now, Janša could very well win them. Paradoxically, it would be harder for him to oppose Croatian entry if he ran the government than if he is in the opposition.

  4. The New Statesman | SLEEPING WITH PENGOVSKY Says:

    [...] Two dasys ago pengovsky wrote that following Sunday’s vote on the Arbitration Agreement put PM Borut Pahor on a track to [...]

  5. Frmr Croatian President Says Janša Is “Unbalanced” | SLEEPING WITH PENGOVSKY Says:

    [...] of Sunday referendum vote provided for some funny moments. One in particular. Former Croatian president Stipe Mesić was [...]

  6. Some People Just Don’t Know When To Quit | SLEEPING WITH PENGOVSKY Says:

    [...] the fact that the people of Slovenia voted in support of the Arbitration agreement between Slovenia and Croatia on a referendum on June 6, the opposition [...]

  7. A Letter To Prime Minister Borut Pahor (Yo B., Wassup!) | SLEEPING WITH PENGOVSKY Says:

    [...] congratulate you on securing, signing and winning ratification of the Arbitration Agreement between Slovenia and Croatia. I for one wholly agree with your assessment that consequences of this agreement go beyond mere [...]

  8. Creative Photocopying Leads To Creative Interpretation | SLEEPING WITH PENGOVSKY Says:

    [...] persecution, revolution, political intrigue, power struggle, secret services, media manipulation, arbitration agreement with Croatia and personal vendetta. Everything you ever wanted to know about Janša’s universe but were [...]

  9. Friday Foxies CCXXXVI (Referendum Special) | SLEEPING WITH PENGOVSKY Says:

    [...] such as the Arbitration Agreement with Croatia pale in comparison, despite the fact that the Pahor-Kosor deal is probably the single greatest foreign policy achievment since Slovenia joined the [...]

  10. A Day Late And A Dollar Short | SLEEPING WITH PENGOVSKY Says:

    [...] Golobič on some other occasions gave credit where credit was due, especially in the case of the Arbitration Agreement and subsequent revolutionary thawing of relations with Croatia, but in terms of internal politics, [...]

  11. Constitutional Court OKs Referendum on Family Code | SLEEPING WITH PENGOVSKY Says:

    [...] True, the institutions of the state are there primarily to protect the weak from the strong. In the big picture the weak got the short end of the stick this time around. But there are ways to go around this (albeit huge) setback. One is to change the constitution. This has been done before. Another way is to do your abso-fucking-lutely everything to help the legislation survive the referendum vote in face of terrible odds. This, too, has been done before. [...]

  12. Lies, Damn Lies and the Campaign Against The Family Code | SLEEPING WITH PENGOVSKY Says:

    [...] this campaign the amount of lies has reached unprecedented levels. Even the referendum on arbitration agreement with Croatia saw less bullshit produced by those who opposed it. Indeed, this time around we saw the whole [...]

  13. How Borut Pahor Is Turning Into A Slovenian Joe Lieberman | SLEEPING WITH PENGOVSKY Says:

    [...] In fact, he and his government had the right instincts and addressed the correct issues. The arbitration agreement with Croatia alone is enough to give the man a Medal of Honour. The fact that he tried to offset the first [...]

Search